Moving Insurance vs. Valuation: What's Covered

June 11, 2026

When your mover damages a box of belongings, who pays — and how much? The answer depends on which liability option you chose at booking. Valuation coverage is not insurance; it is the legal limit of a mover's liability under federal law. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) requires every licensed interstate mover to offer two options: Released Value Protection (free, ~60 cents per pound per item) and Full Value Protection (paid, repair/replace/reimburse at market value). A third option — true moving insurance from an independent provider — exists outside the mover's contract entirely.

---

What "Valuation" Actually Means

The word "valuation" trips up a lot of consumers. It sounds like an appraisal or insurance policy, but under FMCSA regulations (49 CFR Part 375), valuation is simply the level of liability a mover agrees to assume for your shipment. It is not a regulated insurance product and is not backed by a state insurance commissioner.

That distinction matters in practice. If a mover damages your furniture under valuation coverage, you file a claim directly with the mover — not an insurer. The mover's obligation depends entirely on which valuation tier you selected in your contract (the bill of lading). If you selected neither option explicitly, federal rules default you to Released Value Protection.

---

Released Value Protection: The Free Default

Released Value Protection is the minimum liability level required by federal law. Every licensed interstate mover must offer it at no charge. The coverage ceiling is **60 cents per pound per article**, as defined in 49 CFR Part 375.

Here is what that means in real numbers: a 40-inch monitor weighing 15 pounds, lost by the mover, yields a maximum claim of $9.00 — regardless of what the monitor cost. A sofa weighing 120 pounds, destroyed in transit, is worth at most $72.00 in this tier.

Released Value Protection is adequate for shipments where the replacement value of goods closely matches their weight — think heavy outdoor furniture or exercise equipment. For electronics, artwork, instruments, or jewelry, the gap between weight-based payout and replacement cost is often enormous.

To select Released Value Protection, you must waive Full Value Protection in writing on your bill of lading. If you do nothing, you are also placed in this tier by default.

---

Full Value Protection: The Comprehensive Mover Liability Option

Full Value Protection is the higher of the two FMCSA-mandated options. Under this coverage, if an item in your shipment is lost, damaged, or destroyed, the mover must do one of the following:

**Repair** the item to its pre-move condition, OR
**Replace** it with an item of like kind and quality, OR
**Reimburse** you for the current fair market replacement value

The mover chooses which remedy to apply — you cannot require them to replace rather than repair, or vice versa.

Full Value Protection is not free. Movers set their own rates, but pricing is typically tied to the declared value of your shipment. As a rough benchmark, industry practice often runs approximately 1% of declared shipment value — so a shipment declared at $25,000 might carry a Full Value Protection charge around $250, though this varies by carrier and by any deductible you select.

**Deductibles:** Movers may offer Full Value Protection at multiple deductible levels (for example, $0, $250, $500 deductible). A higher deductible lowers the upfront premium but raises your out-of-pocket exposure on a claim.

**Exclusions to know:** Full Value Protection often excludes items packed by owner (PBO boxes) and high-value articles (items worth more than $100 per pound, such as jewelry, antiques, or collectibles) unless you separately list and declare them on your bill of lading. Check your contract carefully for a high-value inventory form requirement.

---

Third-Party Moving Insurance: True Insurance Coverage

Neither Released Value nor Full Value Protection is an insurance policy in the regulated sense. If you want actual insurance — issued by a licensed insurer, subject to state insurance regulation, and backed by the state guaranty fund — you need a policy from a third-party provider.

Third-party moving insurance typically covers:

Damage or loss regardless of mover fault (including acts of nature, traffic accidents, or theft)
Items excluded from Full Value Protection (PBO boxes, high-value articles)
The gap between a mover's Full Value Protection payout and actual replacement cost

Many homeowners and renters insurance policies include limited off-premises personal property coverage that may apply during a move. Review your existing policy's "transit" language and any sub-limits before purchasing a standalone product.

Third-party moving insurance comes with premiums, deductibles, and policy terms that vary by provider. Costs generally range from 1% to 3% of the insured value, but you should get a specific quote based on your shipment's declared value and move distance.

---

Side-by-Side Comparison

	Released Value Protection	Full Value Protection	Third-Party Insurance
Cost	Free (required by law)	Paid; set by mover (~1% of declared value, varies)	Paid; typically 1-3% of insured value
Liability basis	60 cents per pound per article (FMCSA minimum)	Repair, replace, or reimburse at current market value	Policy terms; may cover fault and no-fault loss
Who pays claims	The mover	The mover	The insurer
PBO boxes covered	Yes (weight-based only)	Often excluded	Policy-dependent; often covered
High-value items	Yes (weight-based only)	Only if declared on high-value inventory	Often covered with declared value
Regulated by	FMCSA (federal)	FMCSA (federal)	State insurance commissioner
Best for	Low-value, heavy shipments; tight budgets	Most interstate moves with moderate-value goods	High-value shipments; full fault/no-fault protection

---

How to Decide Which Option to Choose

Start with the contents of your move, not the price of coverage. Walk through each room and estimate replacement cost per item. Then weigh that total against what Released Value Protection would actually pay at 60 cents per pound.

**Choose Released Value Protection if** your shipment is mostly heavy, low-cost goods (basic furniture, appliances) where replacement cost is low relative to weight, and you are comfortable absorbing loss risk.

**Choose Full Value Protection if** you have electronics, instruments, art, or furniture where replacement cost far exceeds weight-based value. Read the deductible options carefully and choose a deductible that reflects the smallest loss you can absorb without a claim.

**Add third-party insurance if** your mover's Full Value Protection excludes items you care about (PBO boxes, high-value articles), or you want coverage for mover-independent events such as fire, theft, or flood during transit. Check your homeowners or renters policy first — you may already have partial coverage.

Always verify that the mover you hire is registered with FMCSA. You can confirm a mover's license and insurance status through FMCSA's online lookup at protectyourmove.gov. Unregistered movers are not required to offer either valuation option and have no federal liability floor.

---

Before You Sign: Key Steps

1. **Get a written estimate** — your mover is required by federal law to offer you the valuation options in writing before the move. 2. **Review the bill of lading** — this is your contract. Confirm which valuation option is checked and what declared value is listed. 3. **Complete a high-value inventory form** if you have items worth more than $100 per pound and you selected Full Value Protection. 4. **Check your homeowners or renters policy** for transit coverage before buying a separate third-party policy. 5. **Keep photos and receipts** of high-value items as documentation for any future claim.

For help estimating what your move might cost overall, use the MovingRated cost calculator to benchmark labor and distance rates before you request quotes. Understanding binding vs. non-binding estimates is equally important — the estimate type affects how much you owe at delivery, which interacts with any additional charges for Full Value Protection. Also note that movers often have category restrictions separate from valuation coverage; our guide to what movers won't move covers prohibited and restricted items that may affect how you pack before your move date.

For more guidance on protecting your move, see the MovingRated newsroom.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

**Is moving valuation the same as moving insurance?** No. Valuation coverage is the legal limit of a mover's liability under FMCSA regulations (49 CFR Part 375). It is not an insurance product and is not regulated by a state insurance department. True moving insurance is a separate policy purchased from an independent, state-licensed insurer.

**What does Released Value Protection actually pay if my item is damaged?** Released Value Protection pays a maximum of 60 cents per pound per article, as required by federal law. If your mover damages a 10-pound laptop, the maximum payout is $6.00, regardless of the laptop's purchase price or current market value.

**Does Full Value Protection cover everything in my shipment?** Not always. Most movers exclude items packed by owner (PBO boxes) and high-value articles — items worth more than $100 per pound such as jewelry, antiques, or collectibles — unless they are listed on a separate high-value inventory form before the move. Read your contract carefully.

**Can I use my homeowners or renters insurance for a move?** Possibly. Many homeowners and renters policies include off-premises personal property coverage that may extend to items in transit. Sub-limits, deductibles, and exclusions vary by policy. Contact your insurer before the move to confirm what applies.

**How do I file a claim if my mover damages my goods?** For valuation claims, you file directly with the moving company. Under FMCSA rules, movers must acknowledge your claim in writing within 30 days and settle or deny it within 120 days. Document damage with photos before the movers leave and note any damage on the delivery receipt.

**Who can I contact if my mover refuses to honor a claim?** You can file a complaint with the FMCSA at protectyourmove.gov. FMCSA enforces consumer protection rules for licensed interstate movers. For intrastate moves, contact your state's consumer protection office or department of transportation, as state rules apply.